Bobcat E35 vs E42 Which Size Do You Need
The Bobcat E42 represents a step up in capability while maintaining the same user-friendly operating philosophy as the E35. At roughly 9,100 lbs with approximately 42 HP of power output, it bridges the gap between mini and mid-size excavators effectively for most commercial applications.
The additional horsepower translates directly to faster cycle times when moving material or breaking up compacted soil. On a municipal road repair project in Chicago, contractors reported completing backfill operations 30% faster with the E42 compared to the E35 because of improved hydraulic flow and engine torque available at lower RPMs.
Key Specifications:
– Operating Weight: Approximately 9,100 lbs
– Engine Power: Around 42 HP diesel engine
– Digging Depth: Approximately 13 feet
– Maximum Digging Force: Roughly 4,500 lbs at the bucket tip
– Bucket Capacity: Standard 0.67 cubic yard (with larger options available)
The E42 maintains the zero tail swing design while adding enough power to handle commercial-grade excavation work without breaking down prematurely. It’s particularly effective for grading operations where consistent hydraulic pressure and engine response matter more than maximum depth capability.
Head-to-Head Comparison
When comparing these two machines, several critical factors determine which suits your specific application better:
Maneuverability vs. Power: The E35 wins on pure maneuverability due to its lighter weight and smaller footprint. On residential renovation work where you’re constantly positioning in tight spaces, the E35’s ability to fit through standard gateways saves hours of setup time daily. However, the E42 brings significantly more breakout force for breaking compacted soil or concrete without changing attachments frequently.
Hydraulic Performance: The E42 delivers approximately 18% more hydraulic flow, which means faster operation when using hydraulic attachments like breakers or augers. On a commercial utility installation job in Denver, crews noted the E42 reduced attachment cycle times by nearly two minutes per operation compared to the E35.
Operating Costs: While the E42 has higher fuel consumption due to its larger engine and weight, it typically completes jobs faster because of improved power-to-weight ratio. On a 500-hour annual basis, the difference in fuel costs alone rarely exceeds $800-$1,200 depending on local diesel prices.
Resale Value: Both machines maintain strong residual values in the used equipment market, but the E35’s popularity among residential contractors keeps demand consistently high. The E42 holds value better for commercial buyers who need that extra power tier.
Comparison Table
Prime members get free 2-day shipping on tools and materials. Try Prime free for 30 days.
| Specification | Bobcat E35 R2-Series | Bobcat E42 |
|---|---|---|
| Operating Weight | 7,850 lbs | ~9,100 lbs |
| Engine Power | 33.5 HP | ~42 HP |
| Digging Depth | 12’6″ | 13’0″ |
| Breakout Force | 3,100 lbs | 4,500 lbs |
| Standard Bucket | 0.41 cu yd | 0.67 cu yd |
| Price Range | $42,000 – $52,000 | ~$55,000 – $68,000* |
| Best Application | Residential/tight spaces | Commercial grading/excavation |
Bobcat E35 R2-Series Comparison
*E42 pricing is estimated based on current market trends and comparable models; verify with authorized dealers for exact 2026 quotes.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose the Bobcat E35 R2-Series if:
– Your primary work involves residential properties with limited access
– Zero tail swing is critical for your job site conditions
– Budget constraints make the lower entry price essential
– You’re doing light excavation, trenching, and grading daily
– Portability between multiple job sites is a priority
Choose the Bobcat E42 if:
– You need commercial-grade power for regular excavation work
– Breaking up compacted soil or concrete without attachment changes is common
– Faster cycle times translate directly to profitability on large contracts
– You’re operating primarily on municipal or commercial projects
– The additional cost can be justified by increased productivity
Real Jobsite Scenario: On a commercial framing job in Minneapolis, the contractor ran both machines for a week. The E35 handled all foundation work around existing structures where swing clearance was limited. When moving to open lot grading operations, they switched to the E42, which completed the same volume of material movement 35% faster due to superior hydraulic flow and engine torque at lower speeds.
The key is understanding your daily workload patterns. If you’re running one machine for 8+ hours per day across multiple job sites, the E42’s productivity gains will offset its higher purchase price within 6-12 months of operation on commercial work. For residential-focused contractors who move constantly between small jobs, the E35 remains more economical and easier to transport.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Bobcat E35 better than E42?
Neither is “better” — they serve different purposes. The E35 excels in tight spaces where maneuverability matters most. The E42 provides the power needed for commercial excavation and grading work. Your choice depends entirely on your primary applications and job site conditions.
Q: What is the best Bobcat E35 vs E42 for the money?
For pure value considering productivity gains and resale potential on commercial work, the E42 often delivers better long-term value despite the higher initial investment. For residential contractors focused on tight sites, the E35 provides excellent capability at a lower entry price point.
Q: How much should I spend on a Bobcat E35 vs E42?
Budget approximately $45,000-$55,000 for new E35 R2-Series units and $58,000-$70,000 for new E42 models in 2026. Used market prices vary significantly based on hours, maintenance history, and regional demand factors.
Q: What brand makes the best mini excavator overall?
This depends on your specific needs. Bobcat leads in residential/tight-space applications with their zero tail swing designs. Caterpillar dominates commercial fleets seeking maximum durability and dealer support. Kubota offers excellent value for contractors prioritizing fuel efficiency.
Q: Is a more expensive Bobcat E42 worth it?
For daily commercial operation, the additional cost of the E42 typically pays back through improved cycle times and reduced wear on attachments from faster hydraulic response. The E35 remains ideal if your work primarily involves residential properties with limited swing room.
Q: What features should I look for in a mini excavator?
Prioritize zero tail swing design, retractable undercarriage for trailer loading, spacious cab with good visibility, and dealer support network strength. Hydraulic flow capacity correlates strongly with attachment performance across all brands.
Q: Where is the best place to buy a Bobcat E35 vs E42?
Authorized Bobcat dealers offer factory warranty coverage and proper training on both models. EquipmentTrader.com provides access to new and used inventory from verified dealers nationwide. Always verify dealer certification before purchasing used equipment for commercial operation.
This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
